We spent a week here in August of 2014. Everything was as good as or better than we expected. The pictures don't do it justice. The beds are WAY more comfortable than you'd expect in a vacation home, and the whole home is furnished nicely. And we are picky. Everything also seems well thought out. The handyman is incredibly responsive when unforeseeable stuff comes up (in our case, a yellow jacket nest showed up on Sunday and was gone on Monday), the owner runs the logistics of getting you in and out without a hitch, the home is clean and neat, and we never once said "I wish this place had...." The location is a quick drive to the center of town, beaches, great restaurants and whatever else you could reasonably want. If you need to be able to get work done, the office is well laid out with a good wifi connection.
We would recommend this place to a friend, but only if we were reasonably confident that the friend wasn't going to be looking for a place in the Hamptons the same week we were.